ParentsClick Network MothersClick FathersClick Mom Blog Network


Breast not best for all readers?

That headline caught my eye today and after reading the story, I thought this would be the perfect place to discuss and share opinions.


According to the article: "Readers of a US parenting magazine are crying foul over the publication's latest cover depicting a woman breastfeeding, with some calling the photo offensive and disgusting.

"I was SHOCKED to see a giant breast on the cover of your magazine," one woman from Kansas wrote in reaction to the picture in Babytalk, a free magazine that caters to young mothers. "I was offended and it made my husband very uncomfortable when I left the magazine on the coffee table." Read the full story.

Well, moms, what do you think? In poor taste or public overreaction?

posted August 5, 2006 - 4:09am

Comments

See MommySerra's user profile
10
MommySerra wrote 2 years 15 weeks ago

I think breastfeeding in public is totally ok and those that dont like it should just not look and get over it. There are so many other things worth worrying about. I will nurse my son wherever and whenever he wants & I dare someone to question if what I'm doing is wrong or right.

Serra
Wife to Dewayne 6/9/01
Mommy to Dakotah 11/14/02
Madie 5/21/04
Wyatt 5/2/06

See mommycozette's user profile
00
mommycozette wrote 2 years 15 weeks ago

The cover did offend my husband but I told him " It's a woman feeding her child would you be offended if that were a bottle?" He shrugged his shoulders as if I had made my point. I tell people that I did breast feed not always was it easy like the article did say but I was determined to give my child the best. The article had soem real good points on how society affects a woman decision to breast feed. It is a time consuming selfless thing to do. Any woman who breastfeeds MORE POWER TO YOU! And any woman who doesn't I COMPLETELY UNDERSTAND. I breastfed my oldest till he was 6months old and I will do the same with this one. I am a cheater mom as some have called I suplament with formula at the sitters and if we're in public and I just can't get breastfeeding done right then and there. As long as your baby is healthy and happy it doesn't matter what anyone else thinks. Be the Parent you want to be not what everyone else thinks you should be.

Mommy to
Jake 2/15/05
Jackson 6/28/06

See amylynn91403's user profile
00
amylynn91403 wrote 2 years 15 weeks ago

We did it! as dora and my almost 3 yr old always say. i think breast feeding is a perfectly natural maybe not always comfortable way to feed your little ones. I think every woman is entitled to feed her baby in public now i'm not sayign flop is out for everyone to see but carry a light weight blanket with you and wear nursing tops most people never even know your feeding them unless they are staring and rude. and that magazine cover did not affect my hubby in the least actually his comment was "wow, hers are still pretty", lol. when men look at that the first thing their eye is drawn to is the breast, they are men big deal. but the next thing they notice is the baby and it goes from being sexual to be completly acceptable unless they feel uncomfortable with it because they are aroused by it. their problem, not mine. i breast fed both my babies till they were 6 months, both times my birth control made me stop lactating, but it was either that or more babies. Smiley we want to wait till we get a house built before we have our last one and hopefully then i won't have to take any more birth control becuase the hubby will get the snip snip. so i'll be able to breast feed for the full year. there are some women who don't feel comfortable with it, that's completly fine but don't let some jerk decide that for you. make the decision on your own about what you feel. i thought i would be weirded out by it at first but when i couldn't nurse my oldest anymore it actually upset me, it's a bond that your can't get any other way.

mommy to
Amy 9/14/03
Kathryne 8/24/05

See nukemom2's user profile
00
nukemom2 wrote 2 years 15 weeks ago

I think the cover is great. It is important that people see that it is beautiful and normal, not something dirty or sexual.
I was not able to bf my now 8 year old and for years, thought I was harboring guilt for it. I figured out that it was regret not guilt. I regret that bf'ing was not in the cards for us.
I was able to bf my dd and did so for 29 months. I nursed everywhere. I never exposed my "boob" to the public.Never "whiped it out". I have a real problem with how our culture has sexualized women's breasts. Nature intended that they be used to feed our offspring. Interesting how we, the human race, as we become more educated and knowledgable about our world, get further and further away from what nature intended our bodies be used for and turn it into something dirty and wrong.
I feel that moms tend to alienate each other based on this issue. Instead of formula moms vs. breast moms, we should empower each other to become educated and to make choices for our families based on having the knowledge and facts about our options, and support each other, knowing that we each made our choices based on our resources at any time.
Bottom line is breast milk is the complete, best food for our babies. Our breasts were made to deliver it to our babies. Science will never be able to synthasize a more superior food for infants. Formula is *satisfactory* but definatly not equal to breast milk, the formula companies even say so..."breast milk is best" on all of their ads and product lables.
As far as bf'ing in public, I refuse and any mother should, to be forced into a public restroom or to hide in my home in order to feed my baby the most wholesome food possible.

nukemom2-mom to
ds 8 years
dd almost 4 years

See Nett's user profile
00
Nett wrote 2 years 14 weeks ago

I breastfeed for 4 months having to supplement after the first month just to keep her satisfied. I can say that I never nursed 'in public' because I didn't have the grace to get her latched on without several very graceless attempts. Only when I was engorged which was often did she latch on fast and properly (weird since the books said that if engorged there could be issues with the baby latching on correctly). I wish that I'd been better at it, but am very glad that I gave her the best that I could. I don't have issues with breastfeeding in public, but understand how it can make some uncomfortable. I feel uncomfortable when I see some of the 'kids'with their eyebrows pierced and their tongues pierced. It isn't my place to say what is going on with their bodies as long as they aren't shoving it in my face. I've never seen a woman breastfeeding who shoved 'it' into anyone but the babies face. Nett

See maestramommy's user profile
00
maestramommy wrote 2 years 13 weeks ago

Dh and I talked about this subject for a couple of weeks, since it seemed to be everywhere. Our take on this is if everyone would be just a little more gracious and tolerant on both sides, we'd be fine. Bfing moms do what they can to nurse discreetly (there ARE many ways), and everyone else just look elsewhere. Most of the time you can't even tell a mom is nursing. At least that has been my experience.

See MamaHall's user profile
00
MamaHall wrote 2 years 12 weeks ago

You can't deny the facts that breastmilk is best for newborns. You also can't deny the fact that some women physically are unable to breastfeed.
We all want what is best for our babies and as long as we are all doing what we can to achieve that...then what's the big deal? BF'ing moms should never judge or criticize formula-feeding moms, and formula-feeding moms should never judge or criticize BF'ing moms. We're all moms and we're all doing what we can to give our babies the best.

The breastfeeding baby on the cover of this magazine is a beautiful portrait. When it arrived in my mailbox I was flooded with wonderful memories of when I was still nursing my daughter. I thought it was a great way to depict the ultimate bond between a mother and her child.

Kudos to BabyTalk! And Kudos to ALL mommies for doing what's best for their baby however they can!

www.playcafe.blogspot.com

See beachmommy's user profile
00
beachmommy wrote 2 years 4 weeks ago

...and I was a formula feeding mom for all three of my children. I love breastfeeding moms, and was fortunate to have a group of friends who understood that for reasons of my own, I would always "whip out" a bottle and often ask them to do the honors! We have a wonderful family, with three healthy kids - and I am proud of the way we are raising them.

 

Thanks for the wonderful site!

Lauri

See bugandbits's user profile
00
bugandbits wrote 1 year 51 weeks ago

I did not breastfeed my older son.  I pumped milk for 9 weeks.  At the time, I couldn't get him to latch on correctly and I was uncomfortable.   My second son was almost exclusively breast fed for 5 months.  He was a preemie so I felt he needed all the extra help he could get.  Both of the boys also had formula and both did FINE!

 As long as you are discreet when feeding in public, I don't see a problem.  I can understand why someone might be "shocked"  if you just whipped out your breast in public, so just cover up.  Plus, many places are nursing mom friendly in case you need to be completely uncovered.  (I nursed a lot in my car parked away from everyone else for privacy).

Whatever you feel is best for both the child and you is going to be the right decision!  Don't let anyone tell you either way!  Everyone will have their opinions, but make sure you are happy and comfortable.

See froggemom's user profile
00
froggemom wrote 1 year 44 weeks ago

i think it's sad that we even have to have these kinds of discussions.  There really isn't anything more natural than a mother breastfeeding her baby.  Breastfeeding is why we have breasts! the more women breastfeed in public, the more people will get used to it, and the sooner we get over all of this shyness and prudity.

 

Yes, I am a breastfeeding mom.  My son has been exclusively breastfed for 5 1/2 months and we plan on continuing for the first year and then we'll see how it goes.  There are some women who cannot or choose not to breastfeed and that's their choice.  But breast really is best.  we all do what we can to feed our babies.

 

See Peggy's user profile
00
Peggy wrote 1 year 43 weeks ago

The cover should not have offended anyone.  A nipple was not visible.  It is a natural thing.  It is a woman's choice whether or not to breastfeed.  I was not physically able to breastfeed.  I really didn't want to anyway.  More power to the breastfeeding moms.  Just remember that bottle feeding moms are just as good as or better than breastfeeding moms.  You should never judge other people!!!!!  Many of my friends breastfeed.  They don't judge me!  They are very descreet when they do.  I think everyone on both sides just needs to say bigons.

 

See KKsMama0204's user profile
00
KKsMama0204 wrote 1 year 42 weeks ago

I completely agree, do what is best for your family.  I tried to BF my oldest, it did not last long.  THe second BF for 3 months then I pumped for another month and then we were done.  We are trying for #3 and I have not decided which way I am going to go.  My dilemma is that I ahve RA (Rheumatiod Arthritis).  Now, it goes away while I am pregnant (another amazing feat of the human body) but comes back strong at about 6 weeks post partum.  At that point, if it is really bad, and we ahve a feeling it might be this time, then I ahve to go back on all my meds, and breastfeeding will be out of the question.  SO, do I try for as long as I can and then have to worry about fighting to get the baby to switch to bottles or just start witht he bottle. It is just a tough decision to make. I loved the idea of Breast feeding my babies, but it is really a tough decision now.  I hate going into public and getting the looks when I give a newborn a bottle (I babysit and even though the child is not mine I still get looks, they assume he is mine).  It is just so wrong that no matter what you do someone does ot approve.  We are all moms and we do what we can.  Yes, the breast is best, but sometimes there are reasons we cannot breast feed. 

As for the cover, I think it is a beautiful picture of a natural event.  Kudos to Baby Talk!

See sarahj's user profile
00
sarahj wrote 1 year 41 weeks ago

I agree with the fact that it is sad that we have to have these disscusions! It's terrible that people are so offended by something so amazing, beautiful, and natural. Way to go Baby Talk!

See TracyB's user profile
00
TracyB wrote 1 year 37 weeks ago

 It's the natural thing to do!  Isn't BF what people did before bottles were created???  And if it wasn't natural, then why do we have breast that create milk???  I think moms should do what they feel comfortable with.  If it's BF then great! 

Tracy Mommy to Rebecca 3/04 and Brandon 8/05

See doccat's user profile
00
doccat wrote 1 year 36 weeks ago

Breast feeding is absolutely the best thing a mother can offer to her child. No formula can ever replace the most complete baby food. My daughter has been a big eater since birth. My supply can never satiate her thus i had to supplement with MF but I persisted w/ BF and she is still b'feeding until now that she's almost 8 months old. I do nurse in public discreetly and I really dont care after whole, its my choice & it concerns my precious one's life. Anybody can say anything they wish, my daughter will still continue to b'feed as long & as much as she wishes. Smiley To all the moms who have selfless offered their time in b'feeding and have the courage to b'feed even in public - thumbs up to you, to those who can't for one reason or another, it's perfectly fine as long as you're happy with your choice. 

See hootieada's user profile
00
hootieada wrote 1 year 36 weeks ago

I breastfed both my daughters exclusively for two years and would do it again in a heartbeat.  I also understand that it is not for everyone and not everyone can successfully breastfeed.  We should all respect each other's positions/decisions.  The cover on the mag. is beautiful and depicts something completely natural.  Whenever I nursed in public (often), I always thought, "Wouldn't people be more offended if I let my hungry baby scream?"

See zenBelli's user profile
00
zenBelli wrote 1 year 35 weeks ago

Jennifer www.zenbelli.com/profile/zenbelli

I agree with many of the wise opinioins put forth already. What I'd like to add to the discussion is this: This really is an issue for all women because it has so much todo with our society's inbalance when it comes to sexuality. Unfortunately that inbalance get's focused on women's bodies. So when an image of a mother breastfeeding her baby appears, we're such a sexualized society it causes controversy. In time as we work through controversies like these as a society hopefully we can begin to heal our sexuality so that natural experiences like a mother breastfeeding is not such a hot topic. Unfortunately, I believe we have a long way to go in healing our society sexually and it's forums like this where women can speak their truth and power where the change will come from. So kudos to all of you for speaking your minds.

See Jodi C's user profile
00
Jodi C wrote 1 year 34 weeks ago

My daughter was unable to latch on to me to feed, but to me breastmilk was the only option. So, I pumped my milk for 15 months. Breast or formula is a personal choice and not for anyone to judge. I was not offended by the picture at all. It is a classy taken photograph of a mother feeding natures way. Men aren't so offended when they see the cover of Playboy so why should it offend them to see a breast being used the way nature intended. I do feel that there are ways to be discreet feeding in public and that breastfeeding is a private, personal choice and should be kept personal. Personally I would have loved to have been able to have my daughter nurse directly from me for more then 3 weeks but I also wouldn't subject the general public to the sight of it.

  smile, it increases your face value! Smiley Jodi

See AllergyMom's user profile
10
AllergyMom wrote 1 year 34 weeks ago

I thought the cover was cute. I cant imagine my husband being offended. I nursed both of my boys.

 

However, having a 10 year old, it might make me hesitate for a second. But all in all, I'd rather him see it and realize that this is how many babies are fed. Just a part of the body. (but there's still that part of me that might be a teeny bit hesitant)

 

 Take care,

Gina

www.allergymoms.com

See Boone's user profile
00
Boone wrote 1 year 32 weeks ago

I think it's adorable. I think if you're offended by it you may have some greater underlying issues. There's plenty of much more offensive material out there that's up and in your face at most checkout lines in grocery stores. It's a shame that people can take something so beautifully created by God Himself, designed for a purpose, and somehow make it vulgar. Move on and find a more worthy opponent.

See BusyMommy's user profile
00
BusyMommy wrote 32 weeks 2 days ago

How can a breastfeeding baby be something "disgusting". It always surprises me when people seem to be so shocked by breastfeeding. Whether you breastfed your babies or gave them formula, it is a woman's right to choose how to feed her baby.

That cover was very discreet shouldn't have even been an issue. I think it's great they are working to make people more aware of breastfeeding moms.

BusyMommy.us - Surviving Motherhood One Mess at a Time

Please register or sign in to post a comment.

Featured Mom Blog

Motrin Moms: A Baby-Wearing Ad Controversy

See Andra's user profile
posted by
Andra
I opened my inbox early this morning to find out that the mommy blogging community had single-handedly forced Johnson and Johnso... Read more »

All featured blogs »